In my last post, my intention was to go for the Bella Hadid inspired makeup look. However, CHAOS STRUCK.
After a nice long day out, Aaron and I intended to go to a house tour and dinner before settling in for the night. Our tour was at 4:15, so we had to leave by 3:45. I thought that starting my makeup at 3:00 would be enough time!
I was wrong. At 3:38 I was just barely finishing my eyes, with no time for my lips, fake lashes, highlighter, or blow dry and style my hair (I figured a high ponytail with hoop earrings would tie the look together). Aaron insisted we leave on time, so I decided to cut my losses. Ten minutes later I had full on contour, a wave of mascara, and lipstick, with a dress and sparkly earrings. Aaron said I looked pretty, which was nice, but IT WAS ONLY HALF OF A LOOK.
To top it all off, we arrived at the development for the tour on time, only to not be allowed in because the realtor company didn’t let the security know we were coming. They didn’t even pick up the phone when the gate called the house! The audacity! I RUSHED for nothing!
That said, I decided to turn things around and take advantage of a full face of makeup. One of my other makeup experiments was testing the four looks depicted in “Why YOU should change your ENTIRE lip routine to fit YOUR face.” I wanted to test with a full face of makeup, because I felt as though having a bare face with a full lip would be incongruous and throw off my opinions of each look; there I was with a full face of makeup, and no place to go! After we got home from dinner, I assembled the materials, and got to work.
Materials:
- Vaseline Petroleum Jelly (link to product here)
- Sephora Bright Future Concealer in Shade 08, Palmier (link to product unavailable)
- NARS Precision Lip Liner in Rosebud (link to product here)
- NARS Velvet Matte Lipstick Pencil in Do Me Baby (link to product here)
- Almay Color & Care Oil-in-Stick in Raspberry Rush (link to product here)
- Sephora Easy on the Eyes Pallette, shade 30 (link to product unavailable)
- Too Face Chocolate Soleil Matte Bronzer (link to product here)
- Laura Mercier Smudge Brush (link to product here)
- Sephora Rouge Gel Lip Liner (link to product unavailable)
- Bite Beauty Outburst Longwear Lipstain in Sangria Slush (link to product here)
Note on My Procedure:
This procedure suggests a natural, moisturizing lip balm. My lip balms are often drying or too sticky, so I elected to use Vaseline petroleum jelly. In small amounts, I find it takes on color and isn’t too gummy or sticky.
Procedure:
This video contained four “looks” to sample. They will each be enumerated below:
Look 1: The “Natural” Look
- Apply your base, lip balm.
- Apply concealer into the corners of your mouth. Pat in with your finger.
- Fill in your cupid’s bow in a straight line with a lipliner that matches your skin tone (you can go a shade darker than your skin tone, but not lighter). Diffuse into your lip balm.
- Fill in the “gaps” (ie, the overlining sections of your lips with no pigment) with your lip liner.
Look 2: The “IG Baddie” Look
- Complete steps 1 – 3 of the “Natural” Look.
- Overline your lips with a slightly darker lipliner.
- Fill in with matching lipstick.
Look 3: The “IG Baddie” Look, Improved
- Take your neutral lip liner and draw a “U” shape along the sides of your mouth, top and bottom.
- Apply lip balm. REALLY moisturize the lip. Go for something tinted! (for this step, rather than Vaseline Petroleum Jelly, I used the Almay Oil-in-Stick).
- Apply liquid lipstick in dots, then pat in with your finger (I used NARS Velvet Matte Lipstick Pencil, rather than liquid lip, see notes).
- With a small brush,dust a bronzer from the corners of your mouth up into the middle.
Look 4: The Vintage/Flapper Goddess
- Using a deep red color (with either a pencil or a brush), draw a straight line up to the top of your cupids bow, and then straight down to the bottom of your lip. Repeat on other side of your mouth, so your upper lip looks like mountains!
- Using that same red color, draw a straight line (following your lip line, not over lining) down your bottom lip.
- Fill in with a matching deep red.
- Bonus tip: ombré a black shadow into the corners of your mouth for a dramatic finish.
Let’s compare the before and after!
| The Person | The Before | Look 1 | Look 2 | Look 3 | Look 4 |
| Eleanor Barnes, aka “Snitchery” | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
| Me | ![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Analysis:
Obviously, Snitchery’s natural lip shape is fuller than mine (she also briefly had fillers, but I believe she had them taken out at this point). She also has professional lighting on her side, along with a stronger hand at makeup. That said, I found that “drawing in” my cupid’s bow looked almost, obvious? I felt you could tell where my lip was and my cupid bow space was filled in to match. I think that the “IG baddie” look covered it best, but the vintage, flapper lip looked good too. I’m lucky that bright red tends to go with my skin tone the most!
If you click through my photos, you may notice a pattern. Are you ready for an earth shattering discovery?
My lips… ARE UNEVEN.
Yes! The left side of my lip is slightly fuller than the right. I have an angular right side, and a “poofed” left side (I say “poof” lightly because let’s be real, my lips aren’t very prominent).
Because I was at home, and Aaron was working on a project, I didn’t get his take on EACH look. What he saw of look 2, though, he liked! That’s a good as I can take it.
Conclusion:
I feel like my lips are a problem area. I will probably devote more time into finding a way to making them look more proportionate, rather than matching everyone else on Instagram! Also, I think I might benefit by looking at how people who do their makeup professionally daily look in real life, and how their lips look in person compared to what I see on Instagram. Filters are ruining what I consider realistic expectations!
Coming Up Next:
There was an additional bonus to the circumstances that led me to going for the “lips” practice instead of the “Bella Hadid” practice: Snitchery uses a flathead brush to apply bronzer and contour. She also uses a certain palette that both she and Tana (from my previous post) rave about for contouring. That said, the designer/creator of said palette has been out partying like crazy while her state is still in lockdown! Super selfish, not cool. I don’t want to give her my money. I might use this as an opportunity to find a new contour palette. The tutorial requires use of a lighter shade, and the palette I have has light shades, but they don’t have any staying power on my face. With that in mind, part 4 will be “Why YOU Should Change Your ENTIRE Makeup Routine.”
















