I had every intention of finishing this movie challenge with spooky, scary skeletons, nightmares and chainsaws.
Then I read “American Psycho.”
It’s all fun and games when it’s Christian Bale murdering people mostly offscreen and talking about his skin care. I’ll talk about this more in my books post for this month, but the violence and sexual gore of the novel is so absurdly extreme that I was genuinely uncomfortable listening to it on Audible. In short, it’s a very good book, but I’m stripping away some of the truly gory, serial killer movies.
So here we are: teenage girl terror. Today we’ll be looking at The Craft, Ginger Snaps, and Jennifer’s Body. Nothing like teen angst and vengeful bloodshed to take your mind off… yuppie angst and bloodshed. Allons-y!
The Craft (1996)
I said “Let’s go” in French, because this movie practically begins in a high school French class (and I’m pretty sure the higher power referenced in this movie is of French lore, too). The Craft is about a group of high school aged witches befriending the new girl, Sarah, to be the fourth in their coven. They are led by emo witch supreme, Nancy, in a tour de force performance by Fairuza Balk. The fact that she hasn’t had an Amy Adams level of roles in the past twenty years is borderline insulting. Nancy is flanked by Bonnie and Rochelle, who are bullied for their appearance (Bonnie is covered in burn scars, and Rochelle is a perfectly lovely looking girl, but she is targeted for her “nappy” hair). Sarah is seduced (or should I say nearly seduced) by Chris, played by an aloof Skeet Ulrich. IDK when he’s cuter, this movie or Scream, which also stars Neve Campbell, who plays Bonnie!
The coven invoke the spirit of the all-powerful Manon to make their problems go away: Bonnie wishes to be beautiful inside and out, Rochelle wishes for Laura (her bully, portrayed by Christine Taylor, who hasn’t aged since this movie. That’s the real witchcraft at play here), Sarah wishes for Chris to fall in love with her, and Nancy wishes for the power of Manon (but really, to no longer be white trash). Sure enough, Chris begins to follow Sarah around like a puppy, Bonnie debuts burn-free shoulders, and Rochelle watches with delight as Laura slowly begins to lose all of her beautifully bleached blonde hair. Nancy witnesses her violent stepfather strike her alcoholic mother, and her screams cause a cosmic reaction that kills her stepfather, leaving them with an insurance policy big enough to purchase a beautiful apartment overlooking the Bay. All seems well, at first… but as things are with black magic, nothing gold can stay.
I fell in love with this movie roughly seven minutes into it. The music alone is so perfectly nineties riot grrl angst. If I went to that high school, I would have been friends with the coven, honestly. I mean, they shoplift, so I probably wouldn’t hang out with them after school much, but… lab partners? Come to my house to study? My mom will order pizza if you wanna stay for diner!
That said, they’re all a bit mean to each other. All of them bully the witch girls, and the witch girls don’t seem to harbor much kindness to the people around them, either. I guess this was before “A Walk to Remember,” where the bullied rise above the cattiness? Also, I feel like they would need to alter Bonnie’s plotline a little bit, because her scars are almost entirely on her back. They go to Catholic school. No one can see them.
I can see why this movie is so beloved, and why they would want to make a sequel fourteen years later (oh yes, allegedly that’s happening, pandemic notwithstanding). Each actress in the coven did a great job, but they tokenized Rochelle’s character, both within the universe of the film and apparently within our universe. Rachel True (the actress who portrays Rochelle) spoke out after the fact that she wasn’t included in the promotion of the film, and that the other actresses had to say something to get her to be included in press events. I know it was over twenty years ago, but for a film that is so feminist and passes the Bechdel test, I would have hoped for some deeper-level intersectionality.
Nevertheless, we must consider the spook factor: there’s a lot of snake iconography, a couple gross-out moments with bugs, and yes, your classic witch cliches of flying and curses, but this film is honestly more of a dark drama/thriller than a horror movie. Coming-of-age, even, with a mystic twist. 10/10 would watch outside of spooky season.
Ginger Snaps (2001)
You know what’s fun? This movie is about two sisters, and both actresses who portray the lead characters had roles in “Supernatural.” It’s apt, too! The whole movie plays out like an extend “Supernatural” episode. There’s scary monsters. They’re co-dependent on each other. They’re in Canada. It doesn’t get more “Supernatural” than that (okay, “Supernatural” takes place in the States, but it’s mostly filmed in Vancouver and it all looks like Canada. It counts).
In a vein similar to Carrie, the eponymous Ginger’s arrival into womanhood via the beginning of her first menstrual cycle is the catalyst for the events of this film. Considering I’ve made changes, hoping for less gore and violence with the heavy presence of both in American Psycho bumming me out a lot, this film has a LOT of blood and guts. It opens with a child playing with the bloody foot of his gored out dog. There are so many shots of gored out dogs in this movie.
Ginger and her sister Brigitte are isolationists in their high school. Ginger is older by about a year, and Brigitte skipped a grade to be put in the same level as her. They are made fun of for being weirdos, but their attitude, much like that of the coven in The Craft, is equally embittered (it vaguely reminds me of this 30 Rock moment).
Their quiet Canadian neighborhood is being held hostage by a vicious beast that has been killing everyone’s dogs. Brigitte and Ginger sneak out of the house to kidnap the dog of one of their primary bullies as a prank. However, Ginger’s scent attracts the monster! Ginger is attacked, before local pot dealer Sam accidentally runs the beast over with his car. Soon Ginger starts to experience a new kind of change, one that will divide her and Brigitte in ways they never thought possible.
This movie treads the line between black comedy and horror very carefully. The girls are foaming at the mouth with sarcasm. The straight-laced wholesome parents just don’t understand. Sam, who befriends Brigitte, is prepared with a quip. Sam has similar shades of JD from Heathers, only he manages to be the only redeemable male character in this movie, as opposed to a psycho who thrives on chaos. Hey, in 2001, being a drug dealer made you shady. Now, in the right state, you’re making great money and like, that’s not THE WORST money you could make.
Ginger Snaps culminates in a final battle unlike anything I’ve ever seen with this kind of monster. It’s tense, and leaves room for every outcome. The film hits its climax, and then ends, where The Craft had a falling action after its own climactic showdown. I don’t know if I would watch this one again, because bloody animals make me uncomfortable. Still, hats off to them for creativity.
Jennifer’s Body (2009)
This movie is my hipster claim-to-fame. I liked this when it came out, I liked it when people forgot about it, and I have stood nobly by its side as it’s gotten the credit it deserved ten years later. This movie was at peak popularity for Megan Fox. In a manner that is now cringeworthy, all people could talk about back then was how hot she was. She made every attempt to stand up for herself and got labeled “difficult,” and her career hasn’t really been the same since. That said, I would hope that this film is something she is still proud of, because it has since become an iconic piece of feminist horror, and developed a cult following. Again. CREDIT WELL DESERVED.
Megan Fox is paired with Mamma Mia!’s Amanda Seyfried, portraying Jennifer Check and Anita “Needy” Lesnicki respectively, best friends in a tiny town in the middle of nowhere. Needy is a red-faced nerd, with dorky glasses and a quiet demeanor. I mean, they did what they could to make Amanda Seyfried seem significantly unattractive when compared to Jennifer. That said, for all that Jennifer has perfect skin, shiny hair, plump lips, and a body to die for (literally), Jennifer has to eyeroll her way around Needy and her boyfriend, Chip (played by Johnny Simmons, who I remember fondly as “I’m Neil” from “Scott Pilgrim vs. The World”).
Jennifer drags Needy to the only bar in town to see Low Shoulder, a band she found on Myspace (yes, MYSPACE), because the lead singer is gorgeous. The lead singer, by the way, was originally to be portrayed by Pete Wentz from Fall Out Boy. This casting did not happen, but a Fall Out Boy poster features prominently on Jennifer’s wall as a subtle tribute. During the band’s performance, a fire erupts, and the band quickly bails as the bar burns to the ground with patrons and staff inside (some of the patrons are other high-schoolers).
Jennifer, traumatized by the fire, escapes with the band, leaving Needy to get home alone. From that night on, Jennifer is… different. Turns out, Low Shoulder would do just about anything to make it to the big times… even sacrifice a virgin. But what happens when the virgin you sacrifice to the devil isn’t a virgin?
I remember liking this movie because it seemed mostly void of overplayed high school cliches. Yes, there’s a climactic moment at a spring dance, and it suffers slightly from “I hate this town” syndrome, but the school isn’t super divided by cliques. A jock dies in the fire, and Jonah, another jock, openly cries in class over the loss, accepting a “nerd”‘s sympathetic shoulder touch for comfort. There’s no gaggle of cheerleaders that Jennifer associates with over Needy. Everyone, for the most part, gets along. Despite the obvious unreal plot points, it felt (at that time) like a more accurate depiction of what I felt high school was like for me.
Megan and Amanda have incredible chemistry in this film, and it’s kind of a testament to their talent that they aren’t best friends in real life. That said, Adam Brody sheds his indie loving Seth Cohen prepster look to take on the guyliner and “edgy” tattoos of Nikolai, the lead singer of Low Shoulder. Equally self-involved, with none of the outward paralyzing self-doubt. Sounds like perfect Satan fodder.
Seeing as how this movie has lived rent-free in my mind for the past ten years, I have multiple thoughts on it. For one, Jennifer and Needy attend their spring formal, and they’re both in just… super unattractive dresses. I think the point of Needy’s was to emphasize that they have less money, and her dress was likely second-hand or homemade, and her mom curls her hair to a wild oblivion. Jennifer’s dress is fine, but nothing special. I wonder why that was their choice. Secondly, Needy refers to Jennifer as being “socially relevant,” which I have used to describe influencers ever since the first time I heard the expression. Speaking of influencers, one of the internet schadenfreude girls I try to avoid recently did a cosplay of Jennifer, and while in real life the two look nothing alike, the cosplay was pretty well nailed.
The soundtrack of this movie is all indie and pop-punk, with the likes of Florence and the Machine and All Time Low being featured. Low Shoulder performs a song in the bar called “Through the Trees,” which could be easily placed into any episode of “One Tree Hill,” “The OC,” “Riverdale,” you name it. However, most of all to me, the soundtrack features “New Perspective,” one of my favorite Panic! at the Disco songs.
The ending is incredibly satisfying (the most satisfying of the three films in this post), but the opening line of this movie is so poignant and so perfect that you could place it in front of any of these movies: “Hell is a teenage girl.” The writer, Diablo Cody (who several years prior wrote the critically acclaimed coming of age film Juno), had this to say:
There’s the scene where Jennifer’s sitting alone smearing makeup on her face. I always thought that was such a sad image. She’s so vulnerable. I don’t know any woman who hasn’t had a moment sitting in front of the mirror and thinking, “Help me, I want to be somebody else.” What makes it extra affecting is that she’s stunning.
That thinking transcends so beautifully in Jennifer’s Body, and it can be seen in all of the women in these movies. Hell hath no fury.





